I've never rode one so I can't comment other than to say "Does it really matter"? I have found that alot of companies throw a ton of money at the rags to "showcase" their stuff. If thats what the rag says is the bike of the year, they are entitled to their opinion!
Cheers,
Jamie
USRiderNews picks the best of the new models each year in 5 broad categories. Style, Engineering, Nostalgia, Value and Comfort